Comedy, Reviews, Hannah McGill

10 articles

Sorted by popularity / date

The Stoker (Kochegar)

17 May 20134 stars

A strange, dark and clever Russian black comedy with an unexpectedly forceful moral message

Edinburgh’s beloved Filmhouse cinema has chosen an unusual and intriguing curio for its first release as a distributor. Directed by the prolific Alexey Balabanov - known for his unflinching but darkly comic fables of the Russian criminal underworld…

Bernie

18 Apr 20133 stars

Jack Black and Shirley Maclaine star in this nicely-mounted but ultimately oddly bloodless comedy

We’re all familiar with the clear-cut outrage that follows a heinous crime perpetrated by a dark, twisted monster against a dewy innocent – but what if it’s the other way round? What if someone hugely popular does something terrible to someone widely…

Much Ado About Nothing

26 Feb 20134 stars

This lo-fi project from Joss Whedon is an elegant adaptation of the Shakespearean play

It’s not classed as one of Shakespeare's hard-to-categorise 'problem plays', but there’s plenty that’s problematic in this mid-period comedy. The traducement, rejection and humiliation of the innocent Hero, for instance – and her capitulation thereto…

I Give it a Year

4 Feb 20131 star

Abysmal, humourless newlyweds comedy starring Rose Byrne, Rafe Spall and Anna Faris

Nat (Rose Byrne) is a shallow, uptight career girl. Josh (Rafe Spall) is an insensitive, laddish boor. For reasons we don’t glean, since it all happens during the opening credits, they get married, and proceed to be vile to one another, until, within…

The Perks of Being a Wallflower

3 Oct 20124 stars

Sincere and witty coming of age drama staring Ezra Miller, Emma Watson and Logan Lerman

Were space aliens to seek an insight into Earth society via the portal of American pop culture, they might be forgiven for coming away with the impression that boy adolescents bear the upper hand in most things. Blame The Catcher in the Rye, perhaps…

back to top

The Campaign

27 Sep 20122 stars

Half-hearted political comedy starring Will Ferrell and Zach Galifianakis

The director of Meet the Parents answers a not-exactly gaping need here: welcome to another comedy in which Will Ferrell plays a particularly pompous and idiotic member of a profession prone to pomposity and idiotism. One does begin to fear that the…

Revisiting: Husbands

18 Sep 20124 stars

Cassevetes' scripted comedy drama veers from the ridiculous to the sublime

It’s hard to star rate this one, on account that it veers from the ridiculous to the sublime with little shilly-shallying in between. As married men in the aftermath of a friend’s untimely death, John Cassavetes (starring and directing), Peter Falk and…

Liberal Arts

10 Sep 20123 stars

Gentle indie romcom from How I Met Your Mother's Josh Radnor

A successful and beloved US sitcom star delves into his soul, and finds there a story of revisiting one’s past, coming to terms with one’s mistakes, and getting it on with a gorgeous, playful, precociously wise young woman. That was how the world got…

Ruby Sparks

7 Sep 20124 stars

Thoughtful, engaging romcom from the makers of Little Miss Sunshine

The directors of Little Miss Sunshine deal once again with the clash between romantic idealism and vulgar, messy reality, in a thoughtful, engaging romcom that draws great work from its central pairing. Paul Dano – Little Miss Sunshine’s mournful…

Jeff, Who Lives at Home

18 Apr 20123 stars

The Duplass Brothers' slacker comedy bears too much resemblance to its underachieving protagonist

(15) 83mins No one would have believed in the last years of the 20th century that of all the stars to emerge from Judd Apatow’s extraordinary talent nursery Freaks and Geeks, the household name would end up being Jason Segel. He’s not as gorgeous as…